Call For Judgement: What if...

Cayvie's proposal, Balancing Act, will create a new rule called "Hats." Well, that's a great name for a rule. As proof, I offer the fact that Rule 3 is already called Hats. (I'm curious to know if that was deliberate.) Several later proposals modify the rule Hats, without specifying which one to modify, including Hat Trick, What Big Hats You Have, and Tricksy Hatses. While the first two are unlikely to pass at present, I like to think that the third may have some merit.

If this CFJ passes, let's assume that those three proposals are all talking about the second Hats rule rather than the first, and we'll also rename the second one Balancing Act after those proposals are enacted or failed, to distinguish between the two.

Passed 12 to 1 by Brendan at 3:48 pm GMT on 4.29.2004.