Proposal : Think Before You Call

[First, a fix - if this proposal fails, we probably should have this part, at least, in another proposal, since "comments of agreement or disagreement" are rather vague, and "more than half of the other players" is a bit of a bastard when there's an odd number of players (5 players, caller not counting, means a total 4-to-1 agreement is required under current rules).]
In the rule "Calls for Judgement", replace "Other Players may append comments of agreement or disagreement to this entry - if more than half of the other Players agree with the call, the Gamestate and Ruleset should be amended as was specified." with "All Players may add comments of agreement or disagreement to this entry, using the FOR and AGAINST icons. If more than half of the Players' opinions (their later votes overriding their earlier) agree with the call, the Gamestate and Ruleset should be amended as was specified."

Append to the rule "Calls for Judgement" the following paragraph:
When a Call for Judgement is resolved, every vote FOR gives 2 Karma to the caller and takes 2 Karma from the accused. Every vote AGAINST takes 2 Karma from the caller, and gives 2 Karma to the accused.

[ie. a Call for Judgement that fails, but just barely, with an even balance, would result in no karma change at all.]

Failed by Kevan, Monday the 20th, -2 Points to Raven's shadow