Call For Judgement: Truman is sleazy
On 5/14 I proposed a proposal Achilles v Tortise. It passed and I was awarded 2 points. In truth I should've received 10 points as it was not trivial. What looks like a lower-case L in the proposal is, you will see, on closer insepction a capital I.
Therefore, things need to be corrected and I should recieve 10 points as the ruleset states for my non-trivial proposal. I changed my health to 44 accordingly. Brendan changed it back, claiming that this does not work since my health is to be set at the median of the others, 36, after being un-idled.
However, the rules state that I should be rewarded 10 health for the proposal. Rule 16 also says:
There is no statute of limitations on fixing the err made when I sleazed things up in the proposal from May. There is nothing in Rule 16 which states that this should not be fixed. It only gives a way to set the health of returning Crew Members, it does not say what changes they can and cannot make to their health because of events in the game, whether they occured before or after being idled.
Vote FOR if you believe that Rule 16 does not block me from fixing the the Admin error in the point awarding, vote AGAINST if you believe that Rule 16 somehow blocks this.
Failed 1 to 8 at 2:31 pm GMT on 6.17.2004.
Therefore, things need to be corrected and I should recieve 10 points as the ruleset states for my non-trivial proposal. I changed my health to 44 accordingly. Brendan changed it back, claiming that this does not work since my health is to be set at the median of the others, 36, after being un-idled.
However, the rules state that I should be rewarded 10 health for the proposal. Rule 16 also says:
16 - Temporary Rule
New Crew Members' Health is set to the median Health of existing crew members (rounded up). Crew Members returning from being idle will have their Health set to whichever of their previous Health and the median Health of existing Crew Members (rounded up) is lower.
There is no statute of limitations on fixing the err made when I sleazed things up in the proposal from May. There is nothing in Rule 16 which states that this should not be fixed. It only gives a way to set the health of returning Crew Members, it does not say what changes they can and cannot make to their health because of events in the game, whether they occured before or after being idled.
Vote FOR if you believe that Rule 16 does not block me from fixing the the Admin error in the point awarding, vote AGAINST if you believe that Rule 16 somehow blocks this.
Failed 1 to 8 at 2:31 pm GMT on 6.17.2004.
<< Home