Call for Judgment

I venture that the SS Eriphyle's 5000-Mutiny Scam should be considered illegal, because the act of Mutiny specifically requires that a Mariner "make a post", and this was not done. (In the huge-loop scams of previous Dynasties, they have always involved the repetition of abstract game actions which do not require any posting or GNDT updating as a step in their execution.)

Whatever Morale the crew of the SS Eriphyle gained from the scam shall be deducted, although they can keep that which was gained by each of their Mariner's first mutinies.

(Unless most of the legal FOR votes for this CfJ are accompanied by the phrase "bad etiquette", in which case these initial Mutiny gains shall also be removed.)