Proposal: The Will of the Hordes

This is an experiment in proposal awards and penalties. The idea is to have grades of (dis)approval given by the voters. The proposer gets or loses Brains equal to the total combination of what all the voters give with their vote.

Create a rule called Vote Grades

This rule takes precedence over rule 5 Voting and rule 6 Enactment.

Trivial proposals are not distinguished from normal proposals.

Hordes vote using 1, 2 or 3 voting icons when voting on a Proposal.

In the event icons are mixed or more than 3 icons are used in a single comment only the last 3 or fewer identical icons are counted.

The award or penalty for a Proposal given to its proposer at Failure or Enactment is 0 Brains plus the sum total of the amounts granted by each vote, which are determined by the following method:

1 FOR or 1 AGAINST or any number of DEFERENTIAL = 0 Brains
2 FOR = +1 Brains; 2 AGAINST = -1 Brains
3 FOR = +2 Brains; 3 AGAINST = -2 Brains

The icons in a vote from the proposer on their own proposal give +0 Brains regardless of the number used.

The total reward or penalty is capped at -20 and +20 Brains.

Failed by Kevan, 19th of December - 7 votes to 10. -3 Brains to Smith.